Story
The Witch-Hunt Never Needed a Church to Work
The machinery that destroyed women in Europe is running in India’s Jharkhand today, and it has many operators.
Nisha Bhagat spent her last minutes asking the world to witness what she could not stop. She wept, apologised to her parents, and named the people she held responsible. Then she was gone. She died after alleging harassment and speaking to a police sub-inspector on the same broadcast.
The question to ask is how a woman with a public voice, a political record and thousands of followers ended up so alone.
Europe answered that question four centuries ago. The witch trials were never a simple story of priests burning women. Many trials ran through secular courts. They worked through a method: denounce the woman, then discredit her, then isolate her. Her neighbours withdrew, the authorities looked away, and when she finally broke, her ruin was read as proof of her guilt. The targets were midwives, healers, widows and women who knew too much and answered to no man. The sin was independence, and the charge was only the instrument.
That method outlived the Church’s monopoly on it. It needs no cathedral, only an institution that calls itself guardian of the community’s morals, and a woman who refuses to stay inside the lines it draws.
Adivasi women know this terrain. The Church has a record here that deserves hard scrutiny. Missions arrived with schools and hospitals and also with a verdict on Adivasi life: that sacred groves, ancestral ritual and women’s customary authority belonged to a lower order. Scholars of colonial conversion, Eliza Kent among them, have shown how new codes of marriage and respectability rewired women’s standing. Churches in modern India still hold land, money and electoral influence, and they should answer for them like any other power. Reverence is no exemption.
But a sharper argument has to face the evidence. In Nisha’s case, the people she named were not bishops. She accused the state government and land brokers of harassing her. Her fight was over jal, jangal, jameen: water, forest, land. Whoever wants the land has every reason to want the woman guarding it discredited. In Jharkhand, land is the real religion of power.
She was also a contested figure. She opposed religious conversion, and that made her enemies. Some of them may have been in the Church’s orbit, and the investigation must follow that thread too if evidence leads there. But a hypothesis is not a verdict. Anyone who announces the Church’s guilt before the evidence does is repeating the witch-hunter’s error with the roles swapped: decide the culprit first, then collect the proof.
Here is what the evidence supports. Nisha Bhagat sought help and, by her own account, did not get it. A police station, which exists to answer exactly this kind of complaint, is at the centre of her allegations. A woman who carried a community’s grievances was turned into a target, and every institution that could have interrupted that process stayed passive or was part of it.
This is what the witch-hunt always looked like from the inside. Nobody had to give the order for her destruction. Each person only had to decline to stop it.
So the movement Adivasi society needs is not an anti-Church crusade. It is a refusal to let any authority, whether priest, politician, police officer, land broker or village elder, decide which women are permitted a voice. That demands three things.
First, a real investigation, independent of the state government she accused, covering the police response, the land allegations and the online campaign against her. The political row is already under way. The BJP has demanded an impartial probe. Both sides will use her death. The test is whether anyone uses it to find out what happened.
Second, an end to the myth that tradition protects women. Defenders of Sarna identity cannot claim Nisha as a martyr while their own networks police women who convert, marry out or dissent. The same vigilance must apply to Church bodies that pressure women to leave ancestral practice. A woman should be free to be Sarna, Christian or neither without paying for it in social ruin.
Third, accountability for institutional silence. Europe’s lesson is that the crowd that jeers and the official who shrugs are as necessary to the outcome as the accuser.
A last warning for anyone who wants her death to confirm a favourite enemy. If Nisha is made a symbol of the Church’s cruelty, or of the state government’s, or of any single villain, the land brokers win. A single villain is a convenient story, and convenient stories close investigations. The structure that isolated her will isolate the next woman, and the one after.
She asked who would bear the cost of her fight. The answer cannot be another family and another daughter.


In 30 Seconds



